Reply to Parliamentary Question on Erroneous Transfers of Monies by Bank Customers
QUESTION NO 2851
NOTICE PAPER 1698 OF 2019
FOR WRITTEN ANSWER
Date: For Parliament Sitting on 2 September 2019
Name and Constituency of Member of Parliament
Er Dr Lee Bee Wah, MP, Nee Soon GRC
Question:
To ask the Prime Minister (a) whether there is an increasing number of cases of monies wrongly credited by a person to a bank account of an individual; and (b) whether our banks are required to freeze such monies and return them to the rightful sender and, if not, why.
Answer by Mr Tharman Shanmugaratnam, Senior Minister and Minister in charge of MAS:
1. With the growth in electronic funds transfers, there have been some reported cases where monies were transferred by bank customers to unintended recipients. This can happen when a person makes typographical errors while setting out the e-payment instructions, but such instances are rare.
2. When such an erroneous transfer occurs, the bank should help by engaging the recipient’s bank, so that the recipient is informed and a refund can be initiated. It is an offence under the Penal Code for the recipient to retain or use the funds when he has been informed that it was sent by mistake. If the wrongful recipient refuses to return the erroneously transferred monies, the sender should make a police report.
3. Er Dr Lee asked whether banks are required to freeze and automatically return monies to a sender when a sender says the monies were wrongly transferred. It would not be appropriate to impose such an automatic requirement on banks. First, a bank cannot be sure that the sender made a mistake. Second, automatically returning the monies to the sender will run the risk of abuse, and does not encourage more careful use of e-payment and transfers.
4. For example, a person who pays for an online purchase could subsequently ask his bank to reverse the payment upon receipt of the goods, claiming that the transaction was in error, and the banks are none the wiser.
5. To address the concerns relating to erroneous transfers, MAS has issued a set of guidelines to protect e-payments users. Under the guidelines, consumers will need to play their part and be responsible for accurate payments. On the banks’ part, they have to make reasonable efforts to assist the sender, as I have mentioned. And in the case of fraud, consumers should report to the Police promptly.
6. MAS will continue to work with the industry to raise consumer literacy and awareness on how to minimise wrongful e-payments. As in the case of cheques, the banks’ role is to ensure that all properly authenticated payment instructions are processed effectively and efficiently. And as customers, we all know we have to write our cheques accurately and properly.
* * *
Related News
-
Media ReleasesPublished Date: 18 November 2026
MAS and Future of Finance Institute Set Out Initiatives in Support of National AI Missions for Financial Services
MAS and the Future of Finance Institute (FFI) jointly announced initiatives in support of the National AI Missions for financial services. These were set out by Mr Gan Kim Yong, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Energy, Trade and Industry (Trade), and Chairman of MAS at the Singapore FinTech Festival on 18 November 2026.
-
SpeechesPublished Date: 18 November 2026
Ministerial Keynote by Mr Gan Kim Yong, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Energy, Trade and Industry (Trade), and Chairman of the Monetary Authority of Singapore, at the Singapore FinTech Festival 2026 on 18 November 2026
At the Singapore FinTech Festival 2026, Mr Gan Kim Yong, Deputy Prime Minister, Minister for Energy, Trade and Industry (Trade), and Chairman of MAS, announced three National AI Missions for Financial Services focused on financial crime prevention, SME financing and safe agentic transactions.
-
Media ReleasesPublished Date: 18 November 2026
MAS and ABS Set Out PayNow Generation 2 Implementation Roadmap
MAS and the Association of Banks in Singapore published an implementation roadmap to accelerate the next phase of PayNow’s development. The roadmap will close the critical gaps identified in Phase 1 of PayNow Generation 2. The upcoming enhancements will make payments simpler, safer and more accessible, expanding the range of payments that PayNow can support and enabling programmable payment processes for businesses and government agencies.